PLATTSBURGH — It was a close race, but incumbent David Monette has appeared to win the Democratic nomination for city councilor of Ward 5.
Monette ended with 121 votes. His opponent, Marvin Shaw, had 106, according to the Clinton County Board of Election’s unofficial results.
The slim margin of victory has triggered a recount July 1 at 11 a.m.
Unofficial results show Monette leading with a margin of just 15 votes, which falls below the statutory threshold of 20 that automatically triggers a recount.
“I’m keeping all of my options open,” Shaw said about the recount. “Every vote needs to be counted because we deserve that in a democracy.
“Every single vote matters, especially in a primary.”
The process will be conducted at the Clinton County BOE office in a transparent, bipartisan manner in compliance with state law, the board said.
“Voter participation in this primary reflected strong civic engagement,” Republican Election Commissioner David J. Souliere IV said.
“We remain committed to accurately counting every lawful ballot and maintaining the highest standards of election integrity.”
Democratic Election Commissioner Mary R. Dyer added they make sure every vote is counted correctly.
“The upcoming recount and audits are important steps in the certification process, and we will provide timely updates to the public,” she said.
For additional information or to request accommodations, contact the BOE at 518-565-4740 or boe@clintoncountyny.gov.
MONETTE COMMENTS
Monette expressed gratitude to voters for their confidence and support.
“I am deeply honored and humbled by the trust that Ward 5 residents have placed in me,” Monette said in a statement Wednesday.
“This victory is not simply about one campaign, it is about continuing the work of building a stronger, safer and more fiscally responsible future for our city.”
Monette, who has served as Ward 5 Councilor since 2024 and lived in the ward for seven years, said his commitment to public service is rooted in values he tries to pass on to his two children: Every person should find ways to serve their neighbors and contribute to their community.
“When I first decided to run, I did so because I believed public service was one of the most meaningful ways I could give back to the city that has been my home for more than two decades,” Monette said. “That belief remains as strong today as it was then.”
During his time on the Common Council, Monette has focused on responsible budgeting, improving public spaces and supporting initiatives that strengthen neighborhoods. He noted that many important projects require persistence and long-term commitment, such as the redesign of the Margaret Street, Boynton Avenue, Sailly Avenue and the Cumberland Avenue intersection.
Looking ahead, Monette said his priorities remain clear: maintain fiscal responsibility; address the city’s housing needs; improve public safety through thoughtful, traffic-calming measures; and continue investments in parks and public spaces.
“The city budget remains one of the most important responsibilities entrusted to elected officials,” Monette said. “Every dollar spent belongs to our neighbors, and we have an obligation to manage those resources wisely, pursue grant opportunities whenever possible and ensure that city government delivers value to residents.”
Monette thanked his supporters, volunteers, family and all residents who participated in the Democratic process.
“I am grateful for every voter who took the time to make their voice heard,” he said.
“I look forward to continuing conversations throughout the ward and earning the support of residents as we move toward the general election.
“Together, we can continue building a city that is fiscally sound, welcoming, and full of opportunity for future generations.”