The town of Oneonta has approved a contract to assess water quality in the Woodland and Southside water districts, after some residents reported brown water coming from faucets and showers.
The concerns were raised during a heavily-attended August town board meeting. The Town Board approved a $102,000 contract with C.T. Male Associates for a needs analysis of the district at a special meeting Monday, Oct. 5.
The district covers the Angel Heights area down into Southside, Town Supervisor Will Rivera said Monday, Oct. 12.
“This is our number one priority to get this taken care of,” Rivera said, adding that he spoke for the town board.
Town Board member Joe Camarata said residents began noticing issues “roughly three years ago” and that he and fellow town board member Brett Holleran were working on the issue together closely last year.
“That’s actually when Woodland was actually hooked up to the Southside wells,” he said, because the Woodland wells are near the Charlotte Creek and were at risk of going into the body of water.
Camarata said about 20 people in the Woodland water district and three people in the Southside district were impacted.
C.T. Male’s proposal said the company will coordinate with the town to review records and existing conditions, “evaluate water quality and operational data, develop a hydraulic model, identify probable causes of deficiencies” and make recommendations.
Rivera and Camarata said the analysis should be done in December, and that it will be used to inform both immediate fixes and longer term investments.
Rivera said that upon coming into office in January, he had difficulty contacting personnel at the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, which had provided the town a grant to address the issues, due to federal staffing cuts.
According to the C.T. Male proposal document, testing by the town indicated “elevated concentrations of manganese” in the water, which may be oxidizing and leading to the discoloration.
SUNY Oneonta Assistant Professor of Environmental Geology Scott Maguffin said via email Monday that “humans need some (manganese) to stay alive but too much is unhealthy for us,” adding that prolonged elevated exposure can have negative behavioral and learning effects for children.
Maguffin said the element cannot be easily filtered out and recommended running cold water until clear before use.
He said a common cause of brown water is disturbed “’scale,’ or the buildup of minerals, inside the pipes that develops over decades.
“Changes in water flow, velocity, and chemistry can remobilize these precipitated minerals and they can come out of your faucet. The engineering study should determine whether that is what is happening here,” he said.
According to the town’s 2025 annual water quality report, the most recent available on the town site, there was 0.0297 mg/L of manganese in a July 31, 2025 water sample. The regulatory limit is 0.3 mg/L, the report stated; that would be about 10 times what was in the sample.