The Niagara Falls City Council will try again in two weeks to establish a local development corporation (LDC) to move forward with the proposed Centennial Park project.
The council tabled a resolution, at its Wednesday night meeting, that would have established the LDC in order to make what Council Chair Brian Archie (D) called “edits” in the proposed by-laws of the agency.
“There are edits I would require to vote (for the LDC),” Archie said. “I believe we should give (the city) the ability to do (economic development) — but no city dollars should go to it.”
The council chair said he wanted by-law language that would make it clear to residents that “the city has no financial responsibility” if the LDC were to fail. He also said he wanted the corporation’s board expanded to seven members from the current proposal of five members.
“Those are my two things,” Archie said.
Archie has reportedly been leading conversations among city council members and Mayor Robert Restaino on issues such as the size of the proposed LDC board of directors, how those directors would be appointed and clarifying language in the LDC’s certificate of incorporation over the division of financial responsibility for what is now being termed the Niagara Falls Sports and Entertainment Complex project between the city and the not-for-profit corporation.
The council chair has called the discussions “extensive.”
The resolution currently pending before the council authorizes the formation of a not-for-profit LDC to be known as the Niagara Falls Entertainment and Sports Complex Local Development Corporation (NFESCLDC). The LDC would develop, finance, construct, and operate the proposed Centennial Park entertainment and sports complex.
Mayor Robert Restaino had originally proposed a governing board structure for the LDC where the Falls mayor would serve as chair of the board while also appointing two of its proposed five directors. The City Council would have appointed the other two directors.
The pending LDC proposal calls for a five-member board of directors, with two appointed by the mayor and two appointed by the City Council. The fifth director would be jointly appointed by the mayor and the council.
If the mayor and council cannot agree on a joint appointment, the resolution calls for each of them to submit a list of three nominees to the City Clerk. Should those lists have one name in common, that individual would become the fifth director.
Should the lists contain six different names, that group of nominees would be sent to the Chief Administrative Judge of the New York State Supreme Court Eighth Judicial District, with a request that the judge designate a sitting justice in the district to select the fifth director.
If the chief administrative judge were to decline to act, the resolution calls for “the Fifth Director (to) be selected from the (six-member) nominee pool by lot, in a drawing conducted by the City Clerk at a regular meeting of the council open to the public.”
Archie did not indicate how his proposed two “community voices” would be appointed to the LDC board.
Council Member James Perry (D) was the only city lawmaker opposed to tabling the LDC resolution.
“We keep throwing roadblocks into this,” Perry said.
Archie disagreed.
“People have to be on board if we’re gonna do this,” he said. “I wanna do this. I’m just asking for two little changes.”
Restaino has championed the creation of an LDC for the Centennial Park project. He has said an LDC offers “several significant advantages” over having the city act as the developer for Centennial Park.
“This is a proven structure for delivering a major public facility, and it is the right approach for Niagara Falls,” the mayor said when first announcing plans for the corporation. “An LDC gives us a dedicated, purpose-built organization with the legal authority to access tax-exempt financing, pursue grants, negotiate the complex development and operating agreements a project like this requires, and deliver a world-class arena and events center for our residents and visitors. It also provides a structure to protect the city against financial exposure related to the project.”
The city has retained a special outside counsel to assist in creating its LDC. Attorney Terry Gilbride, from the Buffalo law firm Hodgson, Russ, led the creation of the LDC to oversee the construction of the new Highmark Stadium for the Buffalo Bills.
Council members have been consulting with Gilbride on changes to the proposed bylaws. Archie has indicated he will reach out to Gilbride again in the next two weeks.