The Niagara Falls City Council once again voted down a move to establish a local development corporation (LDC) to move forward with the proposed Centennial Park project.
A council resolution that would have created the Niagara Falls Entertainment and Sports Complex Local Development Corporation (NFESCLDC) was defeated on a 2-3 vote Wednesday night when Council Member David Zajac (R), a supporter of the proposed Centennial Park project, balked at creating what he described as “another quasi-government entity.”
“For more than three years, residents were repeatedly told by the (Restaino) administration that securing the property (for Centennial Park) was the critical hurdle. We were assured that once the site was acquired, the state’s commitment and enthusiasm would follow, the funding would become available and this project could move forward,” Zajac said in a written statement given to reporters after the council meeting. “So where is the money? Before we create another quasi-government entity, establish another layer of bureaucracy, or ask individuals to begin developing plans for this project, we need to know how it will be paid for.”
Zajac demanded a “firm commitment” from New York State identifying the “funding and resources” to make Centennial Park “a reality.”
Council Members Vincent Cauley (R) and Bridgette Myles (D), who both oppose building the Centennial Park project, also voted against creating the LDC.
“There is so much we need to do before this,” Myles said. “We’re not ready for this. It’s a shame we’re voting on a $200 million arena when the city is dirty.”
Before the council vote on the LDC resolution, a number of members of Ironworkers Local 9 spoke about the need for new development in the city. Russell Kramer said that when he first joined the union, he had to move to Omaha, Nebraska, to find work.
“I hope the kids from (the Falls) in our apprentice program don’t have to do that.”
Tim Hall, another Local 9 member, said the park project is “about more than just construction.”
“I want to see our city thrive,” Hall said. “It’s time to give people a reason to stay.”
Council Chair Brian Archie (D) had taken the lead in negotiations with Mayor Robert Resatino (D) in shaping how the LDC would operate, including the size of the board of directors, how those directors would be appointed and clarifying language in the LDC’s certificate of incorporation over the division of financial responsibility for the project between the city and the not-for-profit corporation.
“I tried my very best to do this,” Archie said after the meeting.
Restaino had originally proposed a governing board structure for the LDC where the Falls mayor would serve as chair of the board while also appointing two of its proposed five directors. The City Council would have appointed the other two directors.
The defeated proposal called for a seven-member board of directors, with three appointed by the mayor and three appointed by the City Council. At least one of the mayor’s and the council’s appointees would have to have been “community representatives.”
The seventh director would have been jointly appointed by the mayor and the council.
The LDC would develop, finance, construct, and operate the proposed Centennial Park entertainment and sports complex. Restaino has championed the concept, arguing that an LDC offers “several significant advantages” over having the city act as the developer for the arena project.
“This is a proven structure for delivering a major public facility, and it is the right approach for Niagara Falls,” the mayor said when first announcing plans for the corporation. “An LDC gives us a dedicated, purpose-built organization with the legal authority to access tax-exempt financing, pursue grants, negotiate the complex development and operating agreements a project like this requires, and deliver a world-class arena and events center for our residents and visitors. It also provides a structure to protect the city against financial exposure related to the project.”
After the Wednesday night vote, Archie said he was uncertain what the next step would be in moving forward on Centennial Park.
“We wanted to take into consideration all the requests (for changes to the LDC structure). I don’t know where we go from here,” he said. “This is a proposal from a mayor that a lot of people are upset with. Had there been clear communication, up front, I don’t believe (the project) would have been met with such harsh rejection.”