The courts, the social safety net, the ballot box, and the snow plow. Most people would be aghast if these quintessential services disappeared, yet few could name the people in charge of them: their county legislators.
While New York’s gubernatorial and congressional races in next week’s midterm elections have dominated public attention, voters will also decide the fate of hundreds of lower-profile but highly consequential county legislature seats.
Counties function as the administrative arm of states. They run assistance programs like Medicaid and SNAP (food stamps), operate sheriff’s departments and jails, maintain roads and bridges, and help fund school districts and community colleges. To raise revenue, they levy sales and property taxes.
“For a lot of our residents,” said Joanne Cunningham, the chairwoman of the Albany County Legislature, “the entry point to Medicaid, SNAP benefits, food assistance, heating assistance, and housing assistance is through the county government.”
New York consists of 62 counties. The five counties that make up New York City (also known as boroughs) surrendered their authority to the municipal government when the city consolidated power in 1898. The five counties still retain borough presidents, but they no longer have independent power.
On Tuesday, just over half of the state’s 939 county legislative seats will be on the ballot. (Check out our tracker of all those races.) Here’s how these often-overlooked governments work.
What are county legislatures?
County legislatures are elected governing bodies that pass laws, appropriate the county budget, and conduct oversight. In some counties, these bodies also have executive power. In others, voters also elect a county executive, who can veto legislation, appoint department heads, and oversee day-to-day operations.
“The role of the county legislature is to check and balance against the county executive,” said Stephen Acquario, executive director of the New York State Association of Counties. “Or if there is no county executive, the board is making those decisions.”
Rachel Barnhart, a member of the Monroe County Legislature, sees herself as a gadfly, spending most of her energy conducting oversight of county leaders.
“I’m very proud of passing the law requiring the sheriff to disclose when he purchases surveillance technology,” Barnhart said.
Besides oversight, legislatures’ most consequential task each year is passing a budget. The largest shares of county budgets tend to go to social services, public safety, and health. Lawmakers work with county agency leaders to balance their requests against available revenue.
Onondaga County Legislator Maurice Brown said he and his colleagues sought a compromise when the sheriff and county executive disagreed on appropriations for new squad cars this year.
“The sheriff needed $1.5 million, and the county executive offered them $250,000,” Brown said. “In the final budget, they got $750,000 because the legislature split the difference.”
County legislatures also pass legislation. For instance, several counties in New York have passed laws this year to ban the sale of kratom, an herb extract that acts as a stimulant. Counties have also passed legislation this year to regulate e-bikes, support Vision Zero implementation, and set taxes on short-term rental properties.
How do they differ from local and state bodies?
Counties are creatures of the state, carrying out its programs and policies on a regional level. For instance, counties help states administer vital programs like Medicaid.
“The way I think about it is we are service providers,” said Reed Cleland, a legislator for Cortland County. “Counties are service providers in ways that cities and towns and villages are not.”
Counties have the capacity to run complex operations that towns and villages can’t due to their small size. But counties and municipal governments often work hand in hand. Most members of boards of supervisors serve in both local and county government. Many counties and municipal governments also have shared-service agreements to coordinate tasks like plowing snow off the streets.
How much do they spend?
The 57 counties outside New York City have a combined revenue of about $37 billion, according to the New York State Association of Counties. That’s larger than the budgets of 23 US states. In addition to property tax and sales tax revenue, counties also receive funding from the state and federal governments. Next year, New York counties will have to spend an additional $1 billion to offset federal cuts to food stamps.
How big are they?
The average county has 16 members on its legislature or board of supervisors. Albany County’s legislature is the largest in the state with 39 members, and Franklin and Orleans Counties are tied for the smallest, at seven members each.
Barnhart said she thinks Monroe County could benefit from a smaller lawmaking body due to the challenges of adequately staffing and reaching consensus among 29 legislators. Small legislative districts also make recruiting candidates more difficult, she says.
“There’s not a huge bench of candidates really to run in some of these places,” Barnhart said.
What about boards of supervisors?
In New York, all counties were originally run by boards of supervisors, which mostly consisted of representatives elected to serve both their town and the county. Today, 16 counties still have a board of supervisors. Each supervisor’s vote is weighted by the population of the town or city they represent.
But most counties now operate on the county legislature model, in which legislators serve only as county officials. Balancing the dual responsibilities of town and county government can be a challenge for some supervisors, according to Jack Marren, the Victor Town Supervisor who serves on the Ontario Board of Supervisors. He said overworked representatives usually prioritize town governance.
“That’s not ideal,” said Marren, “but I understand that if they don’t take care of things at home, they may not be back [on the board] next year.”
Are county legislators paid?
Yes, but pay varies widely. Legislators are considered part-time in most counties, but several lawmakers told New York Focus that it can be a very time-consuming job.
“On paper, it’s definitely a part-time job, but especially around the budget, it’s full-time,” said Brown. “It’s rare that I’m spending less than 50 hours a week. You have to be informed.”
Onondaga County pays its legislators $39,794 a year — and that’s on the high side for the state. The average annual salary is only about $24,000.
As a legislator for Cortland County, Cleland makes $12,000 a year, one of the lowest county lawmaker salaries in the state. He also works full-time for a transportation nonprofit. Most of his colleagues in the legislature are retired, giving them flexibility to attend county meetings that regularly occur during the workday.
“I’m very fortunate to be able to work in a remote, hybrid capacity,” Cleland said. “If I didn’t, I’d have a very hard time being an elected official.”
How much power do they have?
New York’s larger counties tend to have an elected county executive who shares power with the legislature. (Other counties appoint a county manager, a full-time paid administrator who runs day-to-day operations.) Some county lawmakers told New York Focus that executives often overrule them on important decisions.
“We have a very strong county executive system [in Monroe County],” said Barnhart. “And the legislatures end up functioning more like a corporate or philanthropic board than a governing body.”
County executives often have more resources at their disposal than the part-time county representatives, Barnhart added. She thinks a smaller, full-time legislature with more staff could help level the playing field.
“We have to professionalize the legislature,” Barnhart said.