NEWPORT, Ind. — Many farmers spoke out during a public hearing Thursday regarding a proposed zoning change.
They voiced their concerns about the effects on water supplies, air quality, noise, traffic, farmland and nearby homes that they say could be impacted by a Tenaska Energy Plant.
The Vermillion County planning commission continued a public hearing on a proposed 1,500-megawatt Tenaska Energy natural gas power plant, delaying a decision on the rezoning request until at least Nov. 12.
Dave Rank, whose home faces the proposed facility, says he has concerns about the noise, pollution, and water use.
“You have leverage now,” Dave Rank told Vermillion County Commissioners in an earlier meeting, urging them to seek answers before making land-use decisions. He questioned where 10 million gallons of water a day would come from during low-water periods.
“Who in this room wants to live by a power plant? No one,” said Mary Rank–Dave’s wife during the hearing on Thursday.
{span}Rank added in an email, “This proposed plant will use 10-14 million gallons of water daily. Tenaska has not stated exactly where this water will be sourced, but it could have serious impact on towns in Illinois that use the same aquafer for water.”{/span}
Bob Rank also lives in the area and is concerned about the proposed power plant and his family home.
“I live in Edgar County, about less than a mile from the border, and about a mile and a half from this side of this proposed plant,” Rank said. “On August 25, my wife and I broke ground on what we hope to do at our family home. On August 25, we got a letter from Tanaska finding out for the first time about their plans to build this power plant.”
Rank continued, saying his family would have to make some ‘hard decisions now.’
“We hope to raise our twin boys there on the family farm near their grandparents,” Rank said. “We’re not willing to risk their health by raising them so far from a natural gas plant. So now we’re kind of stuck having to decide what to do. And we could cut our losses before we put even more money into the project.”
David Randall, whose family has owned land in the area for years, questioned why the company chose farmland rather than an existing industrial site such as Vermillion Rise. He said the county should use its current negotiating position to get firm answers.
“Your leverage to demand specific, written, publicly available and legally enforceable commitments will never be greater than it is right now,” Randall said.
“Where do lives come in?” Shirley Downs questioned during the hearing. “Where do people come in?”
A representative for Tenaska presented a draft statement of commitments and said the document will be reviewed and discussed.
She also said, “No water gets drawn out of the rise without the county’s consent… No one comes in and gets water from the rise without approval, without consent. In terms of multiple conversations about leverage, there’s certainly truth in the statement that the zoning, rezoning, [and] gating is a strong control point. I would also note that in the commitments, the project commits to drafting and entering into agreements with the county.”
The draft would limit the property to a power plant and supporting facilities, and would bar data centers on the site and cap lot coverage at 20% of the 424-acre property, the representative said. The drafts are not final decisions she added.
“If this land is rezoned, what will really stop other heavy industry from coming here to use this power and the access to the electric grid that it’ll represent,” Randall questioned.
Another public commenter, Kurt Phelps, said regarding whether the land is rezoned to industrial for Teneska, “That farmland will never come back.”
The representative added in response to questions, “If someone approaches you and you are outside of that project for carbon capture and sequestration, they cannot without consent.
Brad Johnson, a county planning consultant, advised the commission not to vote while things remain unresolved.
“Presentations are great, but what they are not is commitments,” Johnson said.
The representative added Tenaska is prepared to lower the proposed sound limit to ‘50 decibels at the nearest occupied dwelling, the representative said. Water sourcing and several other details still required further discussion.”
The commission on Thursday evening voted to continue the public hearing and made no formal decisions on rezoning.