HARRISBURG — Democratic Gov. Josh Shapiro and Republican Treasurer Stacy Garrity stood on stage Wednesday night during Pennsylvania’s only gubernatorial election debate and answered a series of questions. To get those answers out to the public, both candidates were often asked a question more than once.
Shapiro and Garrity won’t debate again before the Nov. 3 election. Wednesday night was the only chance for prospective voters to see them together, debating their positions on a range of issues — from skill games to healthcare, vaccinations to data centers, fuel taxes to public financing for professional sports stadiums and much more.
Hosted by WHTM-abc27 News in Harrisburg, the candidates were given 90 seconds to answer an initial question and 30 seconds for both a follow-up and a rebuttal. Given the format and hard network out at the one-hour mark, some follow-ups and rebuttals were granted 15 seconds when the debate went live.
The candidates agreed that moderators had the authority to redirect their answers when they strayed from the core question. Debate moderators Lisa Sylvester and Dennis Owens, both of abc27 News, found themselves redirecting Shapiro and Garrity multiple times.
Asked about their positions on a potential statewide moratorium on data centers, neither Shapiro nor Garrity answered the question directly the first time. On the second try, Shapiro said his executive order on development from August already effectuated state policy, something a moratorium is used to do.
Garrity used the first 20 seconds of her time to recognize the anniversary of the Oct. 7 terrorist attack against Israel before criticizing Shapiro’s past enthusiasm for data centers. She was asked for specifics as to how long she thinks a moratorium would be needed, and she didn’t give a specific answer; rather, saying she’d support a freeze for “as long as it takes” to allow local governments to update zoning ordinances. She said she believes it could be achieved “quickly.”
The candidates were asked about whether they’d support suspending Pennsylvania’s tax on gasoline and diesel fuel. Neither Shapiro nor Garrity answered the question directly on the first go. And then they were asked a second time.
Garrity proposed a $750 rebate in the summertime using money from Pennsylvania’s Rainy Day Fund. She criticized Shapiro for failing to deliver on a $250 rebate campaign promise made by Shapiro in the 2022 election cycle. She didn’t say whether she’d support suspending the tax.
Shapiro blamed President Donald Trump for waging war against Iran, which is when gasoline prices spiked. To suspend the gas tax would take an act of Pennsylvania’s General Assembly, he said, adding that he was open to it. It took a third question to get the answer.
Similar to the prior two topics, it took two cracks by the moderators to get Shapiro and Garrity to directly answer how they’d approach funding healthcare in Pennsylvania amid federal changes through the One Big Beautiful Bill Act.
Shapiro said something he’s said since early 2025: Pennsylvania can’t afford to backfill the cost of lost healthcare coverage and nutrition assistance. Garrity said she supports the updated work requirements for healthy adults who aren’t senior citizens, disabled or pregnant mothers. The changes, she said, would help direct subsidized assistance to those truly in need.
Garrity was twice asked about her approach to regulating skill games in Pennsylvania. After initially attacking Shapiro’s proposed 52% tax rate, she said on the second question that she supports a simple fee structure per machine rather than a tax.
Shapiro was twice asked about his approach to spending given a near $20 billion increase in state budgets across the past decade and financial analysis that finds the commonwealth has a $5 billion structural deficit. He touted how Pennsylvania’s revenues consistently beat forecasts and positioned the commonwealth as having the strongest economy in the northeast. Asked again, he said he’d likely target “some priorities” that the Republican-led Senate included in the budget but didn’t go into specifics.
It took two questions for Shapiro to address whether he’d serve a second four-year term in full amid speculation that he could be a challenger for the U.S. presidency in 2028. He didn’t commit either time. Initially, he said his only focus is on the governorship and on getting other like-minded Democrats elected in the midterms. The second question saw him shift attention to Garrity, claiming she was the only candidate on stage who pledged to serve a full term.
Garrity replied by saying her pledge applied to her first term. In response to aspersions cast by Shapiro toward Trump, she said Shapiro is responsible for chaos and cruelty in Pennsylvania — turning the governor’s words toward the president back on him — because of late budgets and a lack of transparency around the investigation and settlement of a sexual harassment claim made against a now-former cabinet member, Mike Vereb.
Garrity was twice asked to address whether she shared the vaccine skepticism expressed in the past by Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. Both times she had answered that she herself is vaccinated, including against measles, and she encouraged others to do the same.