The Common Council withdrew a resolution Wednesday after Fire Chief Luca Quagliano challenged that the measure violated the city’s charter and would require additional approvals.
John Craig, 1st Ward alderman and chair of the finance committee, proposed a temporary departmental spending restriction and approval resolution at Wednesday’s meeting.
The resolution cited concerns over limited time to review city expenses and excessive overtime spending. It would have required all city departments to obtain prior approval from the director of finance, city treasurer and mayor for expenditures of $500 or more, with exceptions for departmental emergencies. It would have been in effect until Dec. 31.
Council President Roland O’Malley had already obtained sponsors and second motions for each resolution when Quagliano entered the meeting room and requested to speak.
“I wanted to speak to you to voice my displeasure with the resolution,” Quagliano said to aldermen. Speaking of spending, he said, “I need to come back to you for every purpose?”
David Blackley, corporation counsel, said, “It’s akin to a spending freeze. It’s an added check.”
Referring to the existing process, Quagliano replied, “I can’t get a PO (purchase order) approved without those people anyway.”
Quagliano said the city charter establishes a purchasing process for expenses above $3,000, requiring that a purchase order be sent to the city treasurer. Quagliano said the council had also passed a guideline for purchase of commodities in January.
Speaking of the proposed $500 provision, Quagliano said, “My day-to-day operational costs exceed that. Three individuals already review those things. … Am I supposed to submit everything as an emergency?”
Explaining the reason for the proposed measure, Marcus Wyche, 2nd Ward alderman, said, “It drives it back to the mayor and department heads to put a clamp on it.”
Speaking in favor of the proposed resolution, which she seconded, Kathryn Fogle, 4th Ward alderman, said, “This happens every year. People spend their (city budget) money because it’s not theirs (personally).”
Craig said he would withdraw the resolution.
“In January we’ll have a better process … so people don’t buy two wrenches,” he said.
Fogle said following the meeting, “We need something (in place). We’ve done spending freezes in the past, so I don’t understand.”
When asked after the meeting if purchases between $500 and $3,000 represented the greatest budget problem for the city, Craig said they weren’t.
What prompted the resolution, Craig said, was inadequate review time for city expense reports. Despite a request to receive expense reports on Fridays, Craig said the council still received them on Tuesdays, providing little time to request explanations for the costs. When asked why the change hadn’t been made, Craig said the mayor’s administration had not acted on the request.
Although Blackley reviews resolutions for legal issues, Craig said he also withdrew the spending measure because “I think it was a little unfair and didn’t meet the charter. In 2027 we need procedural processes in place. We gave the department heads the authority to spend their budgets.”
While Craig recalled that the council agreed last winter to have quarterly budget review meetings, the council never moved forward with them.
He had no response to the fact that records show the city had under budgeted or overspent on overtime since 2022, yet the council has not acted on an apparent disregard for budget compliance.
When asked why the council didn’t propose additional spending approvals or hold budget review meetings after the city’s overtime overspending came to light in July, Craig said, “I don’t know.”
O’Malley refused to take questions during the five minutes before the Common Council’s public meeting, saying there wasn’t enough time.