— This story first appeared in New York Focus, a non-profit news publication investigating New York state politics. Sign up for their stories at nysfocus.com/ newsletter.
On Tuesday, the Legal Aid Society asked a judge for a second time to compel the state prison agency to curtail its practice of keeping incarcerated people confined to their cells and dorms for upward of 20 hours a day — or else this time take the extraordinary step of holding the prison agency in contempt. New York state prisons have subjected thousands to such conditions for six months, including during extreme summer heat; the motion alleges that the prison agency hasn’t fulfilled the legal requirements to justify it.
The filing is part of an ongoing lawsuit accusing the Department of Corrections and Community Supervision, or DOCCS, of declaring an overbroad emergency to suspend the requirements of a 2021 solitary confinement reform law across the entire prison system. The law mandates that prisons and jails offer incarcerated people a minimum number of hours outside their cell each day, but allows DOCCS to pause compliance on a facility-by-facility basis during an emergency, which it declared after a prison guard strike in February.
Last month, a judge ordered DOCCS to limit its suspension of the reform law, called HALT, to temporary pauses at individual prisons and offer “detailed facts” about why those facilities warranted the emergency orders. DOCCS then filed a declaration offering extensive data on staffing and conditions in each prison, but didn’t explicitly state which facilities were under states of emergency or when it planned to lift all the suspensions.
With the available information, “it’s not really possible to tell with certainty whether DOCCS is complying with HALT in a given prison,” said Riley Evans, staff attorney with the Legal Aid Society’s Prisoners’ Rights Project.
The filing asks the court to order DOCCS to submit a new, compliant emergency declaration. The court can also hold the agency and Commissioner Daniel Martuscello in civil contempt, the filing argues, which would allow the judge to impose fines or other measures to enforce compliance.
DOCCS, which said it does not comment on pending litigation, has claimed that it has been doing its best to improve conditions given what it describes as a staffing crisis. Facilities adhere to the law when they can, Martuscello has said. He’s said he anticipates reintroducing HALT’s programming requirements by early fall, but has offered little indication of when all facilities will be able to let incarcerated people out of their cells for the law’s baseline of at least seven hours a day (or four for those in solitary confinement).
The filing is the latest development in a years-long dispute between advocates and the prison system over prisons’ implementation of HALT. Since the law went into effect in 2022, DOCCS has attempted to suspend or regulate around HALT’s requirements, including by pushing the limits of its emergency carveouts, as New York Focus has reported.
Tuesday’s motion is also the latest in an ongoing power struggle that has seen DOCCS battling advocates, the state legislature, the courts, and its own staff over the treatment of the more than 30,000 people it incarcerates.
That struggle came to head this winter, as the prison system faced nearly unprecedented scrutiny after corrections officers were caught on video killing an incarcerated man at Marcy Correctional Facility. In February, officers walked off the job, countering the narrative of guard brutality by highlighting what they describe as dangerous working conditions. One of the striking guards’ top demands was the repeal or rollback of HALT.
The strike lasted three weeks and ended with DOCCS firing roughly 2,000 guards, creating the staffing shortage. The prison system remains on pseudo-lockdown, with facilities canceling or severely shortening classes, recreation, therapeutic programming, and work release and limiting out-of-cell time to a precious few hours a day — all HALT violations absent an emergency.
“Martuscello’s filings in the case thus far suggest that he would rather have this law be at his discretion,” said Evans of the Legal Aid Society. “Thousands of New Yorkers are spending weeks and months locked in their cells without meaningful interaction with other people. The stakes here are nothing short of human dignity and torture.”