As the Buffalo Bills prepare to face the Miami Dolphins this weekend, it’s a tale where the former is currently much better than the latter this season and in recent years as well.
The Bills are running away with the AFC East at 8-1, while the rebuilding Dolphins are in the reverse at 1-8. Yet, the latter has played hard in most of their games, giving teams like the Lions and Patriots challenges before losing.
It’s also been a long quarter century since the South Florida franchise has won a playoff game. Let that marinade for a minute.
The Bills have also maintained their dominance over the last near decade, taking 14 of the last 16 meetings, including a playoff game in 2023. While all of that is nice, for those (like me) old enough to remember, the other side was the dominant one and amassed a “decade long” winning streak which no one thought would end, until it did.
From 1970 on, the Dolphins would ascend into a superpower under Hall of Fame head coach Don Shula. After losing Super Bowl VI to Dallas, Miami would achieve perfection, despite not having fellow Hall of Fame quarterback Bob Griese for most of that season due to injury, going 14-0 in the regular season and sweeping all three of its playoff games to win its first championship.
The next year, the Dolphins repeated as Super Bowl Champions. For the rest of the decade, they were competitive yet would not get back to the title game. Amazingly, they missed the playoffs twice despite 10-win seasons in 1975 and 77. However, one thing was a constant: Miami wins over Buffalo every season from 1970-79.
The first time I saw the Dolphins and Bills was in October 1975, one of those agonizing losses, as Buffalo blew a 13-0 lead, with noted Bills killer Don Nottingham scoring three touchdowns, including the game-winner in the fourth quarter to give Miami a 35-30 win. So, five years later, I have to admit I wasn’t feeling confident the streak would end.
In 1980, I was just starting my sophomore year at Niagara Catholic High School. A few weeks before the game, my lifetime friend Dave Pizzimenti is begging me to go to the game. Frankly, I didn’t want to at first, telling Dave I thought Miami would win again.
His attitude was, “Let’s go for the heck of it.”
Frankly, it didn’t take a whole lot of arm-bending to get me to a sporting event. Thus, we went to AM&A’s (remember them?) in the old Summit Park Mall (remember it?) to purchase the tickets. We were stunned to get lower lever corner end zone tickets for the game. Also, thanks to Dave’s late, great dad Tony for taking us to the game.
As for the contest, not a lot happened, as it was 3-0 Bills at the half on a Nick Mike-Mayer field goal. Tony Nathan’s score in the third gave Miami the lead in the third and the here-we-go-again moans were heard at Rich Stadium.
Yet, a pair of fourth quarter scores by Roosevelt Leaks and Joe Cribbs put the Bills in front and a late interception by safety Jeff Nixon — his third of the game — preserved a 17-7 victory, in spite of five picks by Buffalo quarterback Joe Ferguson and each team fumbling four times, losing two apiece.
The goal posts were torn down as you’d have thought the Bills won the Super Bowl. It was that big of a deal!
By the way, the game is on YouTube with the broadcast team of former Denver Broncos and Cincinnati Bengals receiver Mike Haffner and a young, aspiring Syracuse alum who’d go on to a distinguished broadcasting career, by the name of Bob Costas.
A footnote: the Bills’ futility on Miami would continue until 1983, when Cribbs would score the tying touchdown with 23 seconds left and Joe Danelo’s 36-yard field goal in overtime ended a 17-year winless drought at the Orange Bowl, 38-35.
Ferguson, who had the five picks in the streak-busting game in 1980, threw for five scores and 419 yards in the win, while the Miami quarterback was making his pro debut and threw for 322 yards with 3 scores and a pair of picks. That signal-caller’s name? Dan Marino, who rumor has it, turned out pretty good with a gold jacket in Canton.
To the fans, enjoy how good you have it versus Miami. It wasn’t always that way.