An incumbent and veteran Niagara Falls police officer faces a challenge this year for his Niagara County Legislature seat from an urban planner who was once involved in assisting the city’s efforts to revitalize Main Street.
In the 2026 Third District race, endorsed Republican Chris McKimmie will be looking to stave off a challenge from Democrat Matt Chavez.
McKimmie hopes voters see his experience — both on the police beat and in legislative chambers in Lockport — as a strength.
“I see this city for what it is every single day,” he said. “I drive the streets of this city every day I go to work. I know the problems that are effecting this city and I’m able to help solve those problems.”
Chavez, a political newcomer, said he decided to run for office because he believes his background as a community planner with a record of service to area non-profits can benefit the district and county government.
“I looked around at what was going on and thought if I have an opportunity to make a difference, I can’t say ‘no.’ I have to say ‘yes,’ “ Chavez said.
Chavez, 40, was born in St. Louis. He moved to Western New York with his mother and grew up in Amherst. He moved to Lockport, where his wife was born, in 2017. The couple and their children have lived in the Falls since 2020.
His professional background includes positions with non-profit organizations throughout the northeast and Florida, where he worked for Housing Opportunities Made Equal, or HOME.
In Niagara County, he spent three years working for the Niagara Orleans Regional Land Improvement Corp., a municipal partnership that combines the resources of the county and the city to promote redevelopment. Chavez now works for Rodriguez Construction Group in Buffalo.
Chavez, who holds a master’s degree in urban and regional planning from the University at Buffalo, views sound planning as a key ingredient in ensuring roads are paved and plowed, historic buildings are refurbished and communities like the Falls flourish.
“That’s what planning does,” he said. “At its best, it can help facilitate helping people.”
McKimmie, a married, 36-year-old father of two, has been a Niagara Falls police officer for 13 years and currently holds the rank of lieutenant and is a patrol division supervisor. A 16-year veteran of the U.S. Air Force, he also serves as a first sergeant with the 107th Attack Wing at the Niagara Falls Air Reserve Station. He holds the position of deputy majority leader and serves as chair of the county’s community safety and security committee. The Falls native holds a bachelor’s degree in business finance and economics and has a minor concentration in public administration.
McKimmie said he believes his public safety experience has been a plus in the legislature due to his understanding of what’s involved in policing and the resources law enforcement needs to keep the community safe. Now in his third year in the legislature, McKimmie said he’s proud of the role he played in helping to develop the county’s 24-hour ambulance service, which he believes filled an important need for residents.
He also said he’s been pleased with the development of the Buffalo Avenue business district in the LaSallea area of the Third District, which also includes the Town of Niagara. He noted that the county assisted in the development of small businesses and restaurants along Buffalo Avenue with economic development support and through its facade improvement program.
“We invested millions of dollars into small locally owned businesses to retain jobs and improve productivity and improve the appearance of the streetscapes in our community,” McKimmie said.
Chavez agreed there’s a lot to love about LaSalle, especially the quality of life and the reasonable buy-in price for purchasing a home in the area. He said there are a lot of lingering problems, too, including lingering contamination concerns in the Love Canal area and on Cayuga Island.
He believes the county should be playing a larger and more proactive role in helping residents deal with their environmental issues and other concerns. He also said the county needs to do a better job generally of ensuring residents in need have access to the public resources and programs designed to help them.
“The thing I would hope to do as a legislator is making better connections between the resources we have and the people that need them. Sometimes people just need a little bit of assistance. There’s help out there and there’s people that need help and it’s like never the twain shall meet. I think government can have a better role,” he said.
Too often, Chavez said the legislature, which is controlled by a majority of Republicans, adopts a “shake your fist at Albany” attitude that has not been productive.
“We have very serious problems that require real solutions, not looking for fraud that doesn’t exist or arguing against straw men,” he said.
“Basically, I think our relationship with Albany has to change,” he added. “My whole basic idea of government is you can’t just have grievance politics and think things are going to get better.”
McKimmie said he’s knocked on more than 2,000 doors at homes in his district since first running for office and he knows residents’ No. 1 issue remains affordability, which is why he consistently voted to hold the line on taxes and advocated for legislative changes in Albany to help better control utility rates.
McKimmie prides himself on being accessible to the public, touting his monthly “Coffee with Chris” events and meet-and-greets he’s held in the past as examples. He said he’s also supporting ongoing efforts to relocate the Niagara Falls Aerospace Museum from the old Niagara Falls airport on Niagara Falls Boulevard to a location in the tourist district downtown. He said he also remains supportive of the city’s ongoing efforts to revitalize Main Street with help from NORLIC.
If reelected, he said he would continue to focus his efforts on supporting local law enforcement, small businesses and economic development.
“I think we’ve seen a lot in my district,” he said. “I’m very proud of that. I wish we could see that kind of growth all over the City of Niagara Falls.”
Chavez said he got involved with NORLIC, in part, because he believes strongly in reclaiming and revitalizing properties where possible and because he felt Main Street in the Falls had a lot of potential. It’s the same type of potential he sees in valuable neglected properties like the former Wendt’s Dairy location on Buffalo Avenue in LaSalle. He said it’s important to maintain and build up the community’s infrastructure to help grow the local economy.
“People have this perception about public safety being an enforcement issue, but I think when you build your urban environment and you take care of these things and you show you care about windows being broken and grass being cut on municipal properties and things like that, other people take notice,” he said.
As long as the water keeps flowing over Niagara Falls, Chavez said there’s hope in the possibility of a wide-scale renewal for the city. He said it’s going to take strong, thoughtful leadership to continue to steer it in a direction that leads to real progress.
“Niagara Falls is such an incredibly rich place in the sense of tourism, in the sense of renown. Go anywhere in the world and say ‘Niagara Falls’ and they know where you are from. But we don’t benefit from that in the way that we could.”
“There’s ways to clean things up,” he added. “There’s ways to fix things. The question is do we want to?”