ORCHARD PARK — Signing a player like C.J. Gardner-Johnson came with risks and a certain understanding.
Gardner-Johnson has a tendency to create uncomfortability. Sometimes with teammates, sometimes with coaches, often with opponents. So the team that signs him has to live with the results.
“We want to toe the line in everything we do,” Buffalo Bills coach Joe Brady said Monday, “but we can’t cross the line.”
So the question becomes, where do the Bills draw the line? Considering Brady effectively shut down any notion of releasing Gardner-Johnson, the line isn’t at spitting on or at opponents.
Gardner-Johnson was ejected from Sunday’s win over the Las Vegas Raiders for spitting in the direction of tight end Brock Bowers between plays just before halftime. The NFL announced Gardner-Johnson has been suspended for one game for violating Rule 12, Section 3, Article 1, which applies to “any act which is contrary to the generally understood principles of sportsmanship.”
Because the Bills are on a bye, Gardner-Johnson’s suspension begins Oct. 26 and he will miss Buffalo’s game against the Baltimore Ravens on Nov. 1.
Brady called Gardner-Johnson’s decision “inexcusable,” said that it has been addressed — without saying how it was addressed — and was vague as to whether there would be additional punishment from the Bills. But most of Brady’s comments about the situation have been rooted in how it negatively impacted the team, not the disrespectful nature of spitting on someone.
But it doesn’t appear the Bills have plans to release him.
“I don’t need a roster of everybody being the same person,” Brady said. “We want to toe the line, but we don’t want to cross it and we want to be smart about how we handle it. … Obviously, we crossed the line yesterday and that can’t happen. It won’t happen again. … I’m not afraid to have people who are going to try to toe the line in everything they do.”
Spitting, apparently, isn’t far enough over the line.
Gardner-Johnson came to Buffalo — his sixth team in eight seasons — with a reputation for being eccentric on and off the field. San Francisco 49ers fullback Kyle Juszczyk said on X Sunday, “This is the least surprising thing ever. (Gardner-Johnson) spit on me last year when we beat Chicago.”
It is also less than a month removed from Gardner-Johnson calling New England Patriots wide receiver Efton Chism III a “practice squad player” after making the game-winning touchdown catch against the Bills one-handed, something Brady didn’t scold him for publicly.
Gardner-Johnson admitted after the game that emotions got the best of him and that he apologized to his teammates. And Gardner-Johnson again apologized in an Instagram post early Monday morning, but he hasn’t acknowledged spitting at Bowers.
“My passion and competitive nature have always been a huge part of who I am, but I also understand that there is a line that should never be crossed,” Gardner-Johnson wrote. “The gesture I made toward my opponent was inappropriate, unnecessary and not a reflection of the respect that I have for him or this game.”
The incident came not long after Gardner-Johnson whiffed on an attempted tackle of Raiders tight end Michael Mayer, who picked up 13 yards on the play. It was his sixth missed tackle of the season, tied with teammate Terrel Bernard for the NFL’s 10th-most this season.
Before Gardner-Johnson’s ejection, Raiders quarterback Kirk Cousins had gone 11 of 15 for 121 yards. Cousins went 1 of 6 for 5 yards and an interception in his first three possessions afterwards, before turning it on again in the fourth quarter.
Veteran Damar Hamlin — who the Bills use because they know he’s consistent — replaced Gardner-Johnson for the remainder of the game, while rookie Jalon Kilgore saw his first defensive action in dime packages to mixed results.
Some flashy names like Derwin James Jr. (Chargers) and Budda Baker (Cardinals) are rumored to be available at the Nov. 10 trade deadline, but the Bills would need to do some salary cap gymnastics to make either player fit for this season and in the future.
“C.J. is a member of the Buffalo Bills. We brought him here for a reason,” Brady said. “He knows that he has to play better. He knows that he has to be better for this team. Just like everybody else, we have to learn from this stuff and improve and find ways to get better as the season goes.”