PENDLETON — Starpoint was in it until the final whistle, but three turnovers and costly mistakes compounded to end the Spartans’ season at home.
Fifth-seeded Orchard Park blocked a potential game-tying 33-yard field goal as time expired to escape with a 20-17 win over No. 4 Starpoint in a Section VI Class A quarterfinal matchup Friday.
“Small school in A versus biggest school in A, no one gave us a shot, and it took them every play,” said Starpoint head coach Jay Baumann. “This team had a lot of heart, I think it showed in that game. We had many guys go down, we didn’t make excuses. I hope this team gets a little more credit than they got.”
After a 26-yard field goal by Landon Kirk put the Quakers (8-1) up three with 1:27 to play, Starpoint quarterback David Chase led a masterful drive with no timeouts to get his team down to the Orchard Park 5-yard line with 17 seconds remaining.
However, as was a theme for Chase and the Spartans (7-2) throughout the game, things quickly went awry.
On the next play, Chase was sacked for an 11-yard loss, and just barely managed to spike the ball with one second remaining to give his kicker, Cole Steiner, a chance to tie the game.
Steiner managed to get the kick away on a good snap and hold, but it was Orchard Park’s 6-foot-6 John Meka Jr. who burst through the line to get a hand on the ball.
“This was a great game,” Baumann said, “but I’d rather be on the other side of it. It happens.”
Starpoint had multiple opportunities to pull away in the second half, but two of Chase’s three interceptions on the night kept the Quakers in the game.
While leading 17-10 late in the third quarter after Chase connected with Steiner on a 10-yard touchdown pass to open the second half, the Spartans quarterback tried to squeeze a ball in on the sideline, only for it to be deflected and picked off by Orchard Park’s Matthew Wright.
The Quakers took full advantage of the great field position, as Dakota Flynn’s 5-yard rushing touchdown tied the game 17-17. Flynn ended with just shy of 200 yards on 33 carries to go with two touchdowns, gashing the Spartans defense on the ground consistently.
“They had some hog mollies in the middle,” Baumann said. “They’re big, they live in the weight room. They’re well coached, and that’s a stadium team if I’ve ever seen one.”
To Chase’s credit, he shook off the turnovers well, and did so again as he led Starpoint down to the Orchard Park 5-yard line midway through the fourth quarter.
Right when it appeared the Spartans were preparing to retake the lead, a miscommunication between Chase and his receiver allowed Orchard Park’s Zack Danna to secure an easy interception and almost certainly take points off the board for the Spartans.
In the end, Chase finished his final high school game 17-of-28 for just over 200 yards to go with the lone touchdown and three interceptions.
“David Chase was the heartbeat of this football,” Baumann said. “When we turned the ball over, our team did not blink, no one was negative on the sideline. … He was a leader for us, three-year starter, and he’s going to be hard to replace.”
Flynn opened the scoring on a 15-yard touchdown early in the first quarter, which came off Chase’s first interception on his first pass attempt. Keanu Laughton responded with a 1-yard touchdown for Starpoint to tie the game 7-7 in the second quarter.
In addition to his eventual game-winner, Kirk knocked in a 27-yard field goal in the second quarter, while Steiner made a 24-yard kick of his own to make it 10-10 at halftime.
The loss was Starpoint’s first since a narrow week one defeat to Grand Island. It also ended the Spartans’ 7-game winning streak, which was the longest in Section VI entering Friday.
Orchard Park will play West Seneca West in the Class A semifinal, as the Warhawks defeated North Tonawanda to advance. The semifinal will be played at West Seneca West, with a time and date to be announced.